Anxiety disorders: cardiac biofeedback, neurofeedback and self-regulation

The essentials in 30 seconds

Very commonAnxiety disorders are the most common mental disorders worldwide, affecting 470 million people in 2023, according to the WHO.
Evidence-based approachesCognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) with exposure, and certain medicines prescribed by a doctor, are the standard treatments.
Heart rate biofeedbackA meta-analysis of 24 studies links it to a marked reduction in perceived stress and anxiety.
NeurofeedbackEncouraging results, but studies are still of uneven quality: a complementary approach.

Normal anxiety or anxiety disorder: where is the line?

Anxiety is first and foremost a useful reaction: an alarm signal that mobilises the body in the face of danger or a challenge. It becomes an anxiety disorder when fear or worry is intense, excessive and hard to control, lasts for several months and ends up interfering with family, school, work or social life. These disorders often begin in childhood or adolescence, and affect women more than men.

In the bodyphysical signs

  • Palpitations, shortness of breath
  • Sweating, trembling
  • Nausea, stomach aches
  • Muscle tension, restlessness
  • Disturbed sleep

In the mindpsychological signs

  • Overwhelming worries, rumination
  • Difficulty concentrating or making decisions
  • Irritability, nervousness
  • A sense of impending danger
  • Avoidance of feared situations

The World Health Organization (WHO) distinguishes several forms, which can occur together in the same person:

Generalised anxietyPanic disorderSocial anxietyAgoraphobiaSeparation anxietySpecific phobiasSelective mutism
5.8%of the world’s population lives with an anxiety disorderSource: WHO, 2026
470 millionpeople affected in 2023Source: WHO, 2026
Only 1 in 4receives any treatmentSource: WHO, 2026

What happens in the body and the brain

When faced with a threat, real or anticipated, the brain triggers an alarm response: the sympathetic nervous system speeds up the heart and breathing and tenses the muscles. The parasympathetic system, acting in particular through the vagus nerve, works as a brake and restores calm. In anxiety, the alarm goes off too often and too strongly, and the brake struggles to regain control.

Heart rate variability (HRV), that is, the small natural variations in the interval between two heartbeats, partly reflects this balance. Slow breathing, at around six breaths per minute, increases it: this is the principle of cardiac coherence (heart coherence breathing).

The established approaches

According to the WHO, psychological interventions are essential, and those with the most evidence are based on the principles of cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), including exposure, which teaches people to gradually face what frightens them. Learning to manage stress (relaxation, mindfulness) also helps to reduce symptoms. In adults, a doctor may prescribe certain antidepressants (SSRIs). The WHO generally does not recommend benzodiazepines for these disorders, because of the risk of dependence and their limited long-term effectiveness. Any change to treatment must be decided with your doctor.

When should you seek help straight away? If anxiety stops you from functioning day to day, or comes with very low mood or dark thoughts, talk to your doctor promptly. If you are in distress, 3114, France’s national suicide prevention line, is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

Heart rate variability biofeedback: what the research shows

Biofeedback makes a bodily signal (here, the heart rhythm) visible in real time, so that you can learn to regulate it. A meta-analysis published in Psychological Medicine (Goessl et al., 2017) pooled 24 studies and 484 participants: heart rate variability biofeedback was associated with a large reduction in self-reported stress and anxiety, including compared with control groups. However, the authors stress that better-controlled studies are still needed.

Neurofeedback session at Centre Élan
A training session at Centre Élan.
A sensorPlaced on a finger or earlobe, it measures your pulse beat by beat.
Guided breathingSlow and steady, at the pace that feels most comfortable for you.
Live feedbackThe screen shows when your heart rhythm synchronises with your breathing.
Exercises at homeA few minutes a day to consolidate what you have learnt.

Neurofeedback and anxiety: the current evidence

Neurofeedback applies the same principle to the brain’s electrical activity, measured by EEG: visual or auditory feedback indicates, in real time, when activity moves closer to the target state, for example a calmer state of alertness. A systematic review of randomised trials of biofeedback and neurofeedback in anxiety disorders (Tolin et al., 2020) offers a nuanced picture:

What the trials showencouraging results

  • Greater improvement in anxiety than with no intervention (waiting list).
  • Approaches judged to be effective overall in anxiety disorders.
  • A variety of signals studied: heart rate, muscle tension, EEG…

What remains to be showncurrent limitations

  • Superiority over other active approaches.
  • A specific effect, distinct from the non-specific effects of the support provided.
  • Better-quality studies: most are rated “weak”.

In other words, these approaches seem useful, but we do not yet know precisely how much of their effect is due to the training itself. Neurofeedback is not one of the established approaches: it should be seen as a complement to them.

At the centre: learning to regulate anxiety, not to eliminate it

The aim is not to get rid of anxiety altogether, as it serves a useful purpose, but to regain some room for manoeuvre: being able to recognise when stress is building and bring it back down. After a quantitative EEG (qEEG) assessment and questionnaires, training combines the following, depending on your needs:

Cardiac coherence

Heart rate variability and breathing biofeedback, with exercises to practise at home.

Body tension

Measuring muscle tension and stress reactivity, so that you can learn to relax.

Neurofeedback

A personalised protocol based on the assessment, to train a calmer, more settled state.

With your consent, this work is coordinated with your doctor or psychologist. Is work-related stress an issue for you? Find out about our services for businesses and occupational health, and read our article on OCD, which used to be classified as an anxiety disorder.

Complementary support. Biofeedback and neurofeedback are methods for training self-regulation. They do not replace diagnosis, psychotherapy or medical follow-up. Medication, whether anti-anxiety or antidepressant, must never be stopped or changed without the advice of the prescribing doctor.

Frequently asked questions

What is cardiac coherence?

It is a state in which the heart rate varies regularly with the breath, most often achieved by breathing slowly, at around six breaths per minute. In biofeedback, a pulse sensor lets you see live whether the exercise is working.

Does biofeedback replace psychotherapy or medical treatment?

No. It complements medical and psychological care. Cognitive behavioural therapy and, if needed, treatment prescribed by a doctor remain the standard approaches.

Do I need a diagnosis of an anxiety disorder to come?

No. You can come to us for stress that keeps building up, tension or disturbed sleep. The initial assessment is a chance to take stock and, if necessary, to direct you to your doctor.

Sources

FREE GUIDE
Your child’s attention and sleep: the parents’ guide

Get our free guide: 10 practical strategies, drawn from clinical practice and neuroscience research, to improve attention and sleep in children with ADHD, autism or specific learning difficulties.

Then one email a month, no more.

Invalid email address
Newsletter language

Share this article